Wednesday, January 20, 2010

BHA request action after latest attempts to inject creationist ideas into school science learning

BHA have news of "Truth in Science" book aimed at schoolchildren via school library.


The BHA has asked Education Secretary Ed Balls to act against a new wave of propagandist material dressed up as science that has been sent to secondary schools by the creationist organisation Truth in Science.

The BHA previously wrote to the DCSF about Truth in Science in 2006 after the organisation attempted to infiltrate teaching of creationism and ‘intelligent design’ in school science lessons by posting costly free teaching resources to all secondary school heads of science and by encouraging parents to challenge teaching on the origins of species.

The Government distanced itself from the resources sent to schools and, after campaigning by the BHA and others, finally published its ‘Guidance on the place of creationism and intelligent design in science lessons’ in September 2007. The guidance makes clear that creationism and intelligent design are not scientific theories, and so cannot be taught in science lessons, as they have "no underlying scientific principles, or explanations".

Truth in Science has now sent copies of the book ‘Explore Evolution: The Arguments for and against Neo-Darwinism’ to school librarians around the country. The book seeks to undermine the theory of evolution and seeks to have creationist-inspired ideas, such as ‘intelligent design’, implanted as credible scientific viewpoints. In the letter that accompanies the book they argue that ‘the textbook is ideally suited for use in the classroom and for teachers who wish to increase their understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of modern evolutionary theory’.

James Williams, Lecturer in Science Education at the University of Sussex says:

"The book cleverly omits any mention of creationism and intelligent design, but merely contains updated and rehashed creationist arguments. The book is subtly loaded against evolution, yet purports to be a ‘balanced argument’. It is cleverly constructed and leads the reader down a path where the answer always seems ‘obvious’ – design  – it is if you follow their arguments – but the arguments they have loaded in favour of design cannot be balanced.

"Given the backlash against their last attempt to lever intelligent design into UK they have clearly decided to try a back-door route by pushing these books onto a largely non-scientific audience of school librarians. They could be easily be taken in by the glossy production values and miss the arguments loaded in favour of ‘design’. Many unsuspecting librarians may well have placed this on school shelves.

"If the intelligent design community wishes to be taken seriously it must spend its money on serious scientific research and gain acceptance that way. So far they have produced no credible evidence to date, unlike the mountain of evidence for evolution.”
                                                                                     

Notes

James Williams is available for comment upon request. For information or further comment please contact Paul Pettinger on 020 7462 4993.

Wednesday, December 2, 2009

David Flint, Humanists4Science had 500+ signatures for No 10 petition

David Flint, Chairman of Humanists4Science had 500+ signatures (incl. Chris Street) for his No 10 petition:


We the undersigned petition the Prime Minister to include the teaching of evolution by natural selection in the new national primary curriculum. More details


More details from petition creator

Scientists are agreed that all today’s living organisms have evolved over millions of years from simpler organisms. This evolution is best explained by Darwin’s theory of natural selection and its subsequent refinement. Natural selection is the most powerful tool for understanding living things.
The current draft curriculum includes living things but omits evolution and natural selection. These ideas are needed to lay a foundation for later studies and to help children see their place in the living world and the universe.

Submitted by Mr David Flint – Deadline to sign up by: 18 August 2009 –Signatures: 536
This petition was mentioned in The Times, 20 November 2009.

Friday, November 20, 2009

Evolution is to become a compulsory subject for study in all state primary schools - The Times

Evolution is to become a compulsory subject for study in all state primary schools. The Government announced yesterday that Darwin’s theory of how life evolved through natural selection would be a legal requirement in science teaching from September 2011, although it will be left to schools to decide how this is done.

The move, which was welcomed by scientists, comes despite a drive to slim down the national curriculum for primary schools and leave teachers greater discretion over what to teach.

Church and other faith schools within the state system will have to educate their pupils about the theory of evolution, although officials said it could be taught in a context that reflected a school’s ethos, in a similar way to compulsory sex education for children aged under 15.


“You could do that within the ethos of the school. If as a school, in consultation with governors and parents, you have a particular take on that, you would still be able to do that,” said a spokesman for the Department for Children, Schools and Families. The change, included in legislation introduced in the Commons yesterday, follows a review of the curriculum for primary schools published earlier this year by Sir Jim Rose.

A consultation on his proposals to loosen the number of formal topics taught in primary schools prompted calls for the curriculum explicitly to include evolution. More than 500 scientists and supporters signed an e-petition to Downing Street.

The new curriculum is to include a requirement “to investigate and explain how plants and animals are ‘interdependent’ and are diverse and adapted to their environment by natural selection”.

The age at which children must be taught about evolution is not specified; it must be included in science lessons “in the later stage of the primary education”.

The Royal Society applauded the decision and said that it would send booklets to all teacher-training colleges with information and advice.

Professor Sir Martin Taylor, its vice-president, said: “We are delighted to see evolution explicitly included in the primary curriculum. One of the most remarkable achievements of science over the past 200 years has been to show how humans and organisms on the Earth arose through evolution.”

Thursday, November 19, 2009

Humanists4Science welcomes new legislation for the teaching of evolution in primary schools



Humanists4Science welcomes new legislation, introduced today, on primary curriculum reform in England, which introduces compulsory teaching of evolution to ages 5-11 year old children.


Chris Street (pictured) reports that following Humanist4Science July 2009 proposals to the Government, legislation was introduced today (11 November 2009), to make evolution compulsory and explicitly taught to children aged 5-11 years in Primary Schools.

The Department for Children, Schools and Families (DCSF) (19 November 2009) press release states that Evolution will be compulsory in the Primary curriculum from September 2011.


However the Humanists4Science proposal for compulsory teaching of  'The Scientific Method' in Primary Schools, was not taken up.

In July 2009 Chris Street authored the Humanists4Science submission to the Primary Curriculum reform consultation by Jim Rose.


Chris Street of the Humanists4Science group said "this is brilliant news because now children will learn about evolution as early as five years rather than when they are fourteen.


I met Desmond Swayne MP on 10 July to discuss teaching evolution in Primary Schools  and he who wrote to Diana Johnson MP (Parliamentary Under Secretary for State for Schools at the DCSF). I think Humanists4Science have had a direct input into successfully changing National Primary School curriculum legislation."

Andrew Copson, BHA Director of Education and Public Affairs, said, ‘It is fantastic to hear final confirmation that, for the first time, evolution will now be included in the national primary curriculum. Evolution is arguably the most important concept underlying the life sciences. That it had not originally been included in the revised primary curriculum was of great concern and we are pleased to see that has now been rectified.’

source: www.DCSF.gov.uk, 19 November 2009, Major reform to curriculum at the heart of a renewed push to drive up standards.
source: Humanists4Science submission to the Jim Rose Primary Curriculum reform consultation.

Department for Children Schools and Families Press Release


The Department for Children Schools and Families dcsf.gov.uk 19 November 2009 Press Release stated that from September 2011 in Primary Schools:-
"Evolution made compulsory and importance of British history confirmed in new areas of learning"

"Schools Minister Vernon Coaker has today confirmed plans to bring in a new curriculum to shake-up primary education – with overwhelming support from pupils, parents, teachers and experts."
"New legislation introduced today on primary curriculum reform in England will drive up education standards across the board. Vernon Coaker confirmed that evolution will become a compulsory part of science education"
"Due to the positive response to Jim Rose’s proposals, few changes were made to the proposed Areas of Learning. However, after consulting with parents, teachers, the science community and other interested parties, pupils will be expected to explicitly cover evolution as part of their learning. Learning about evolution is an important part of science education, and pupils already learn about it at secondary school."
Background


The independent review of the primary curriculum, the first in ten years, was led by educational expert Sir Jim Rose and began in spring 2008. The new legislation is based on his report, which sought the views of teachers, parents, pupils and subject experts and took over a year to complete. The Government accepted Jim Rose’s recommendations in full in April this year. The BHA, Humanists4Science and others commented on his review by 24 July 2009.





  • in the Science, Life and Living sections include:-
    • Charles Darwins’ theory of Evolution by Natural Selection - the single most important idea underlying the life sciences. 
    • how organisms are adapted to their environments and how variation can lead to evolutionary changes.’ 
    • children should understand that, over time, organisms have evolved.
  • the Key Stage 4 curriculum (pg 224) states: -
    • Organisms and health - In their study of science, the following should be covered: 
      • a) organisms are interdependent and adapted to their environments 
      • b) variation within species can lead to evolutionary changes and similarities and differences between species can be measured and classified 
  • Humanists4Science recommend that part of the Key Stage 4 curriculum be included in the later stages of the Primary Curriculum viz. 
    • ‘to apply knowledge and understanding to describe how organisms are adapted to their environments and how variation can lead to evolutionary changes’ 
  • Humanists4Science recommend addition of notes:-
    • L14. to apply knowledge and understanding to describe and explain the structure and function of key human body systems including reproduction 
    • L15. to investigate the structure, function, life cycle and growth of flowering plants and explain how these are linked 
    • L16. to investigate, identify and explain the benefits of micro-organisms and the harm they can cause 
  • Humanists4Science welcome the example of the study of Evolution and Darwin (page 48) included in the report under Cross-curricular studies:-
    • ‘Schools that chose the 200th anniversary of Darwin’s birth to launch a study of this famous Victorian and his lasting contribution to science included learning about the journeys of the Beagle, mapping the route to the Galapagos Islands and the climate and conditions revealed through the voyage which furnished Darwin with a wealth of evidence for his theory of evolution.‘ 
  • Conclusion: 
    • Humanists4Science consider that Evolution be specifically mentioned in the Primary Curriculum.

Humanists4Science Proposals on Scientific Method.
Humanists4Science proposed (pages 16-17) that the 'scientific method' be included in the Primary curriculum.

We recommended that the scientific and technological curriculum be amended to:-

Pupils develop valuable skills in applying scientific method, that is generating and testing ideas, gathering and making sense of evidence, developing possible solutions, and evaluating processes and outcomes. They learn to distinguish evidence from opinion and communicate their findings in a variety of ways."

"essential knowledge should include "a direct reference to the value of science as a way of finding out true facts.

"addition of "how the scientific method enables us to learn truths about reality". Humanists4Science proposed that key skills, taken together, make up the scientific method. and that  scientific method skills are needed by children to make progress:’

"Conclusion: Humanists4Science consider that Scientific Method be specifically mentioned in the Primary Curriculum."

Submission by Humanists4Science





Who are Humanists4Science?
Humanists4Science (H4S) group is for humanists with an active interest in science. We believe that science is a fundamental part of humanism but also that it should be directed to humane and ethical ends. Science is, in our view, more a method than a body of facts. H4S seek to promote, within the humanist community and beyond, the application of the scientific method to issues of concern to broader society.

Wednesday, November 11, 2009

Scientists win place for evolution in primary schools


The government is ready to put evolution on the primary curriculum for the first time after years of lobbying by senior scientists.
The schools minister, Diana Johnson, has confirmed the plans will be included in a blueprint for a new curriculum to be published in the next few weeks.
It follows a letter signed by scientists and science educators calling on the government to make the change after draft versions of the new curriculum failed to mention evolution explicitly.
The open letter sent in July to Ed Balls, the children's secretary, was signed by 25 leading figures from science and education, who urged the government to rewrite the curriculum before it was finalised.
Among the signatories were the Oxford University evolutionary biologistRichard Dawkins, three Nobel laureates and Reverend Professor Michael Reiss, the professor of science education at the Institute of Education in London.
The letter expressed alarm that the theory of evolution through natural selection, which it describes as "one of the most important ideas underlying biological science", was ignored in the revamped curriculum.
"We consider its inclusion vital," the letter said.
In a letter to the British Humanist Association (BHA), which has co-ordinated the campaign for evolution on the curriculum, Johnson confirmed it would be in the final draft. Pupils will start with simple concepts of change, adaptation and natural selection illustrated by the evolution of fish to amphibians to mammals, for example.
Andrew Copson, director of education at the BHA, said: "Evolution is arguably the most important concept underlying the life sciences. Providing children with an understanding of it an early age will help lay the foundations for a surer scientific understanding later on. I congratulate the government for taking on board the contributions from so many supporters of science education."
The government asked its primary school adviser, Sir Jim Rose, to overhaul the curriculum for four- to 11-year-olds last year. His report in the spring set out widespread reforms to the curriculum.
It recommended stripping away the 11 subjects primaries must cover by law, and replacing them with six "areas of learning", including history, science and geography. In the next few weeks, the results of the consultation on Rose's plans will be published along with the government's response.
Copson said the teaching of evolution was particularly important in the wake of a recent survey commissioned by the British Council, which found that 54% of Britons agreed with the view that "evolutionary theories should be taught in science lessons in schools together with other possible perspectives, such as intelligent design and creationism".
Johnson said: "Learning about evolution is an important part of science education, and pupils already learn about it at secondary school.
"The draft primary curriculum was designed to cover evolution as an implicit part of the new programme of learning for science and technology. After a public consultation on the plans – which took in the views of parents, teachers, the public, subject experts and other interested parties – it is expected that evolution will be covered explicitly in the new primary curriculum. The responses from the consultation will be published shortly."

Tuesday, November 10, 2009

Inclusion of evolution in primary school science - NOW CONFIRMED!!

source: http://www.humanism.org.uk/news/view/386
The BHA has today 8 November 2009 welcomed a statement from the Department of Children, Schools and Families (DCSF) that the theory of evolution is to now be included in primary school science lessons in England.

In April this year the government began consultation on a new primary school curriculum, which like its predecessor, failed to make any mention of the theory of evolution or process of natural selection.

During the summer the BHA organised a public letter from a group of distinguished scientists and science educators, calling on government to include evolution in the primary curriculum. The BHA made its own submission to the consultation and encouraged members and supporters to do the same, as well as petitioning MPs and ministers on the issue.

In a letter to the BHA from the DCSF, minister Diana Johnson MP has now stated that ‘We have considered the consultation reports...and the views expressed on this issue by the BHA and members of the science community. As a result of the consultation you will be pleased to know that evolution is now included in the programme of learning for scientific and technological understanding.’

Sunday, August 16, 2009

Drop GCSEs. We should be teaching our children to think

Peter HymanAug 15, 2009 23:05:00 GMT
This is related to teaching primary kids scientific method.
Politicians should stop worrying about whether tests are being 'dumbed down' and provide pupils with the right tools for life
"If I put a bunch of flowers in the back of a computer, does the computer become a vase? Everyone spend a minute thinking please. Let me stress there is no right answer." This was the start of my assembly for 240 11-year-olds at a west London comprehensive a few weeks ago. Pointing at a boy in the second row I ask: "What do you think?"
"It can't be a vase, the computer wouldn't hold water."
"I don't agree," another says. "You could put water in the back and push in the flowers and then it would be a vase."
"No, the water wouldn't stay," a student answers. "A vase has to be curved, so it can hold water."
"A vase has to be pretty, that's the point of it," says a nervous girl at the back.
"So what is the definition of a vase?" I ask. "Could this be a vase?" I say, holding up a dustbin. The students look thoughtful.
"If I put this bunch of flowers in my mouth," I say, clutching four wilting daffodils, "and put water in my mouth, am I a vase?" I start to put the flower stems in my mouth. There are rumblings of "yuk" from the hall.
"No, whatever you do you're not going to be a vase," one girl says emphatically.
"So where have we got to?" I ask.
A serious-looking boy answers: "The computer is not a vase; it is only acting as a vase for that moment. It is changing its identity, sir."
This question, about flowers and computers, is one of hundreds of "thunks" – "questions that make your brain go ouch" – compiled by educationalist Ian Gilbert to get students to think. Yet surprisingly, children spend very little of their time in school thinking. There is almost an unspoken deal: we'll spoonfeed you the required nuggets of information to pass your exams if you behave and do your homework on time. Our education system is not designed to get children to think. Why?
Because even now, after some streamlining of subjects, teachers have huge amounts of content to plough through. Because teachers often do not have the techniques or confidence to engage in open-ended, probing questioning. Because in some schools there are crowd-control issues that get in the way. There is perhaps one further reason. We don't prize thinking in this country. We are suspicious of the intellectual; it's almost as if we believe too much thinking is not a good thing.
Using a power-point slide, I give my students some of the theory of educationalist Benjamin Bloom. There are six levels of thinking, starting with the most basic, knowledge, and progressing to understanding, application, analysis, synthesis and evaluation. Lessons where students have to evaluate and justify their answers, synthesise many sources of information or create, for example, a new experiment in science using the principles they have learnt in previous lessons, all involve higher-order thinking.
Yet too many lessons do not get beyond information-giving and that's often because exams test knowledge and some understanding but not a lot else. That means much of a child's education is spent on low-level thinking. The result is, sadly, that the imagination and potential of too many children are dulled.
The traditionalists would say that the main problem is ignorance of basic information. The conclusion of these critics is that schools don't teach this stuff any more. They do, of course, with bells on. A thousand years of British history has been compulsory since 1988. The question is why aren't students retaining the information? The answer: probably that there is too much focus on imparting knowledge and not techniques for understanding, explaining and then using that knowledge.
While passionate subject specialists are essential to bring a subject alive (my students were almost salivating when they got their hands on some original correspondence between Churchill and Hitler held at the magnificent national archives at Kew), freely available information on the internet means that the role of the teacher must now be changed (many are already doing this). They need to focus on students acquiring a way of thinking, a series of transferable techniques, that can be used in a range of situations.
This week I, like many teachers, will share the anxiety of my students awaiting exam results, worrying about my GCSE history students in particular.
The truth is that the annual debate about whether exams are too easy or too hard misses the point – which is whether the exams test the right sorts of things. In my view, they don't. GCSE exam results are not a true reflection of the talent of my students or anyone else's. GCSEs are based on the assumption that students leave school at 16, which most don't. Yet politicians of all parties are too scared to get rid of them. It's time to scrap them and have a series of pathways from 14 to 19, with students able to take relevant exams and do extended projects at the times that suit them. The best schools are starting to offer this already.
Much has been achieved in education since Labour came to power in 1997. There is more funding, better teaching and improved literacy, though there is a huge amount still to be done to ensure that every child enters secondary school reading and writing properly. What has not been cracked is a policy for secondary schools.
With the government preoccupied with an education policy focused, it seems, more on "community cohesion" than learning and teaching, and the Tories believing, strangely, that another bout of structural reform is going to raise standards, what is being neglected yet again is what matters most – what goes on in the classroom.
What has been missing is a fundamental debate about the sort of students we want leaving school at 18. What skills do we want them to have? What toolkit should they have to thrive in the world they will enter? If we want Britain to succeed, we need students leaving school with the qualities – teamwork, creativity, perseverance – that will prepare them for their working lives. When employers are asked what skills they want from students, they regularly put good oral communication at the top of the list. Yet too few students leave school having the confidence to perform in front of an audience or present an articulate case without notes.
Many schools are now rebelling against the old way of doing things and devising lessons that explicitly teach students the best ways of improving their learning. I have spent several months working with some excellent teachers at my school to devise a new thinking skills curriculum for the 11-year-olds starting secondary school in September. The aim is to provide them with the tools – critical thinking, analysis, public speaking, reflection, leadership, independence, love of reading – that will encourage good learning habits and prepare them for a life enjoying learning.
Yet unless politicians get behind it, every school that does something similar will worry that Ofsted or the government will expose them for not drilling their students enough in the antiquated exams they sit.
My assembly ends with a final thunk: "What colour is a zebra when you remove the stripes? Find me in the playground later today and give me an answer. But when you leave this hall, remember one thing: school is for thinking."
Peter Hyman is deputy headteacher of a London comprehensive. He was political strategist to Tony Blair from 1994-2003 and is the author of 1 Out of 10.
guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2009